top of page

Others could run 666 local stations on the BBC's £100m local budget

Writer: David Lloyd
David Lloyd
19 minutes ago
4 min read

A Dorset local radio station has done some excellent work recently in challenging the Council about traffic markings put down without the necessary traffic order causing chaos on the high street and upsetting local traders. After the station pointed out the issue, they were removed – but leaving concerns about the cost and quality of the work. Again, the station is pursuing the matter.


On Remembrance Sunday, as parades and services took place in Rutland and Stamford, one station was across the area in Uppingham, Stamford, Oakham and Oundle – supplementing its coverage with a special podcast and videos on social media. Little wonder that 86% of the station’s listeners say they feel more connected to their area thanks to it being there.


A station in the Yorkshire Wolds whirred into action when a new free car park in Driffield was handed over on time to the County Council but with most of road markings/signage absent, leading to traffic issues. All three councillors were interviewed sharing residents' frustrations. With the press office declining to comment, the station took the issue directly to the County Council Leader. Internal meetings were convened and the matter was rectified.


These three stations, steeped in their patches were not run or funded by the BBC. Step forward Alfred, Rutland & Stamford Sound and Great Driffield Radio striking the balance in championing their areas and yet holding to account when necessary.


Stations like these exist across the country doing great work in their communities on-air, online and in person. They do so when in good hands, with bright brains, imagination, and calling sensibly upon all available technology - with modest and uncertain budgets.


Meanwhile, the BBC says there’s not enough money to run 39 now highly regional operations on around £100m. It is laughable.


And let’s be clear. Last year the BBC spent about £100m on programming alone on these stations.  That does not include the huge amount it spent on everything else including all the generous premises and FM and DAB transmission.


There are many people who could spend that money more wisely – including many gifted hard workers at local bases at the BBC itself – sitting powerless – frustrated by their lanyarded ‘leaders’.


One of the operators of the community stations above calculates he could run 666 local radio stations on his model for £100m.


Now, they would not be the same as BBC local stations – but there’s a heck of a difference between 666 stations and 39 part-time operations, however they are defined. (And, remember, the BBC spends far more than £100m anyway).


But even with its bundles of cash, the BBC is slashing local radio. More cuts. The extra shows it promised just a year ago are failing to materialise. And the local sport the BBC said was safe is no longer safe.

What is happening to the BBC’s distinctiveness? What about the BBC’s specific Public Purpose to “serve the diverse (UK) communities”? Who is supposed to be regulating this?


Ofcom conducts public consultations on changes to the BBC’s Licence which give it ever more freedom to do ever less.


When the BBC applies for Licence changes, it persuades Ofcom that little will change – and that it will sugar the pill with exciting new extras.  Ofcom chooses to repeat these feeble promises to the public.  But the assurances are quietly forgotten – and Ofcom cannot then insist upon delivery as it did not include them in the face of the flawed Operating Licence.


Ofcom claims these impenetrable consultations are “clear” to the public and “as simple as possible” – as they must be under the regulator’s own consultation principles.  However, when one complains about a breach, Ofcom then takes a year (by my experience) to even decide whether to consider whether to investigate because they say the same matters have a “level of complexity that means the exercise is not straightforward”.  They cannot be both simple and complex.


The public have never been asked whether the dismantling of BBC local radio was a good idea.


Ofcom has fulfilled few if any of its pledges to: monitor carefully audience response to all the changes: monitor output; monitor where programmes are originated from; conduct appropriate research; analyse other research appropriately.


Ofcom is required to ensure that the BBC does what the Charter says. But how does Ofcom know whether the BBC is “represent(ing) and serve the diverse communities” of the UK? Aside from glancing at a few headlines from a bit of quant research, how does it really know if listeners in Bradford, Leicester, Bournemouth or Manchester are hearing the “most creative, highest quality and distinctive output”. If they were hearing a lot three years ago and half as much this year, will Ofcom know? Will it have anything to say?  


Why does Ofcom nod sympathetically at the BBC’s poverty-pleading when it knows full well from the annual financial returns it requires and holds from non-BBC stations, how many of the latter manage on such little cash – despite heavy obligations.


Ofcom is a brilliant regulator for many complex jobs. I fear this is not one of them


Sadly, the BBC is proving itself an incapable operator of local radio and the money could be better spent elsewhere; and Ofcom is proving to be a regulator ill-suited to this particular job.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page