BBC Guilty of Licence Breach


The BBC has today been found guilty of not delivering sufficient local hours of broadcasting on its local radio stations in the year 24/25, despite its obligations being reduced.
The BBC has breached its Ofcom Licence.
This follows a review by Ofcom, which also criticised the accuracy of the BBC’s historic compliance reporting.
The BBC has misled its regulator.
The BBC is given public money to deliver programming in line with the provisions of an Ofcom Licence. It failed.
I complained a year ago about this matter to the BBC, as the process requires. The BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit assured me many times that it was compliant – and that its record keeping was meticulous. Ofcom now says it wasn’t either of those things. That seriously undermines the confidence we can have in the BBC’s own complaints process.
The BBC's complaints process has failed.
Ofcom took eight months to decide whether to investigate my complaint – versus the fifteen days its procedures indicates. It never decided whether to open an investigation – yet now it has published an outcome. That is not transparent and not in line with Ofcom process. It is also not a timescale which gives any confidence in BBC regulation.
Ofcom appears ill-equipped to handle BBC complaints.
The BBC reported incorrect figures to Ofcom a year ago which Ofcom failed to check before publishing in its annual report on the BBC, despite giving written assurances to other complainants that it would check – and despite indicating in consultations that it would keep its own records to verify this exact point.
Whilst the figures were declared as correct on the face of last year’s Ofcom report on the BBC – there is no correction on the face of this year’s annual report published today. Ofcom itself would require equal prominence for such a correction by a broadcaster.
Ofcom Consultations were flawed
When the BBC asked for Licence changes to give further freedoms with local radio hours, Ofcom issued public consultations which it insisted were simple and understandable. They were not - as is self evident by the complexity of the issue above. If the consultations are so complex , they are not compliant with Ofcom consultation principles. As such, Ofcom's decisions based on those consultations are accordingly unsound.
The last consultations also failed to indicate that, at the time, the BBC was failing to honour its existing commitments - and the changes it requested were to remedy that situation hurriedly. Would Ofcom's recommendation to agree the BBC's request had been different had it considered the request more thoroughly?
The BBC has not been held sufficiently accountable for its failures.
The BBC has been sent a stiff letter "setting out our wider concerns
regarding its governance, assurance and reporting arrangements as well as our expectations for future compliance and reporting" and the Deputy DG has to write to me about all this.
I'm sure they'll look forward to explaining their naughtiness to the next door neighbour. The BBC, however, has not been sanctioned for these failures, yet other radio stations with far fewer resources and revenues are sanctioned for far lesser offences. It would have been fitting for the BBC to have been sanctioned and the managers who operate BBC local radio to have volunteered to pay the penalties from their own salary. The current Deputy DG of the BBC was one of those responsible for BBC local radio in this period.
Whilst Ofcom merrily highlight the smallest isolated failure of an independent station -here we have a serious failure by the publicly-funded BBC over a lengthy period buried in this annual report. This failure should be published separately.
If we cannot trust the BBC Complaints Unit - and it takes almost a year for Ofcom to arrive at a conclusion after a covert process, the regulation of the BBC appears thoroughly flawed.
As for BBC local radio – it is required to do very little. And we can't trust it to do even that.
------------------------------------------------------------------
LETTER FROM OFCOM TO DAVID LLOYD 19th NOVEMBER 2026
Dear Mr Lloyd, CAS-8233074 – Outcome of Ofcom’s initial assessment of your complaint
Thank you for bringing your concerns regarding the BBC’s compliance with condition 4.40.6 of the Operating Licence to our attention. We appreciate your patience while these matters were being considered.
Following our assessment of the issues you raised and our engagement with the BBC, the BBC reviewed its historic compliance reporting and acknowledged that six local radio stations did not comply with the requirements of Condition 4.40.6 during 2024/25. Its revised analysis showed that these shortfalls were relatively small and ranged from 0.5% to 2.7% of the relevant quota.
The BBC also acknowledged inaccuracies in information previously reported to Ofcom regarding compliance with this requirement. After careful consideration we have decided not to take enforcement action in this case. We do not consider that such action would lead to better outcomes for audiences or help secure compliance beyond the steps already taken.
In reaching this decision, we considered the nature of the issues identified, the BBC's acknowledgement of the breaches and its commitments to implement measures to strengthen its compliance arrangements and address the causes of those breaches. However, our assessment did identify concerns regarding the accuracy of the BBC’s historic compliance reporting and the governance and assurance arrangements supporting it, including the fact that these compliance issues were not identified by the BBC in its response to your initial complaint.
We therefore considered it important that these concerns were addressed publicly, along with the BBC's acknowledgement of them and the steps taken to address them In the Compliance Annex to our BBC Annual report, we set out these concerns and the compliance issues identified.
We have also published a separate letter to the BBC setting out our wider concerns regarding its governance, assurance and reporting arrangements as well as our expectations for future compliance and reporting. In that letter, we said we expect the BBC to explain to you the outcome of its review and the actions it is taking in response. We will continue to monitor the effectiveness of the measures implemented by the BBC in response.
We appreciate the time and effort you have invested in raising these matters. Your complaint directly contributed to the outcomes described above. I can assure you that we take the BBC’s conduct very seriously indeed.
Yours sincerely, Cristina Nicolotti Squires
OFCOM REPORT INTO BBC Annual Report 25/26
COPIED BELOW FROM ANNEX 1 OF OFCOM REPORT ON THE BBC ANNUAL REPORT 25/26
Condition 4.40.6 – Local Radio hours in England Compliance issue A1.9 A1.10 A1.11 A1.12 The compliance issue concerns inaccuracies in the BBC's reporting of compliance with Operating Licence Condition 4.40.6. In July 2025, the BBC reported that all 39 local radio stations had met the locally-made programming quota for 2024/25, leading Ofcom to record the BBC as compliant. Following a complaint regarding the BBC's compliance with Condition 4.40.6 of the Operating Licence for the period 2024/25, Ofcom sought further information regarding the BBC’s compliance reporting methodology and supporting evidence for local radio output. As part of this assessment, Ofcom raised concerns about the accuracy of the reported figures and the treatment of certain programming counting towards the quota. Following a review of all 39 local radio stations, the BBC acknowledged there were discrepancies in its reporting and it informed Ofcom it had now identified that six local radio stations had not met the requirements of Condition 4.40.6 during 2024/25: BBC Radio Norfolk, BBC Radio Essex, BBC Radio Cumbria, BBC Radio Shropshire, BBC Radio Coventry and Warwickshire and BBC Radio Stoke. The BBC acknowledged these were breaches of Condition 4.40.6 and it identified the shortfalls ranged from 24 to 133 hours, representing 0.5% to 2.7% of the relevant annual quota. The BBC informed Ofcom that the inaccuracies resulted from shortcomings in its reporting methodology and associated processes, including issues arising from the implementation of Local Radio Value for All. The BBC also stated that it was taking steps to strengthen the accuracy, monitoring and oversight of local radio compliance reporting. Ofcom’s response A1.13 A1.14 Ofcom takes any breach of the Operating Licence seriously. Having considered the circumstances of this case, including the nature of the breaches, the BBC’s acknowledgment of them and the BBC’s commitment to implement measures to strengthen its compliance arrangements, we do not consider it would be appropriate or proportionate to take enforcement action at this time. We have written separately to the BBC today to set out our concerns regarding the effectiveness of its governance, assurance and compliance reporting arrangements. Ofcom will continue to monitor the BBC’s compliance reporting and its implementation of the measures intended to strengthen oversight of compliance with this condition.



Comments